Perfect Jack O’ Lanterns and a Tip About Orange
It’s almost Halloween, so I decided it’s about time to take one of the most common Halloween cookies of all, and jack him up a few notches. Get, it, jack him up?! HA HA HA, okay, you’re not laughing…
ANYWHO, I like the dimension and puffiness of a sectioned pumpkin, but I don’t how it looks to add a face on top of the base layer. It might be a bit on the OCD side, but I like realistic.
So here’s what I do. First, I use an food color marker to sketch out my jack o’ lantern’s face. If you want them to be uniform, use a stencil. After you have the face planned out, use flood icing to add a thin layer to fill in the sections you made.
Let that dry. Then use orange piping icing and a #2 tip to outline the facial features and divide the pumpkin into even sections.
Flood the face in by filling alternating sections, giving them about a half an hour to dry in between, then moving on to the remaining sections. This will give your pumpkin a LOT of dimension. If you like the “lift” I get from my icing, use thicker flood icing…somewhere between 12 and 20 seconds. The thicker it is, the higher it will go.
Let that dry, and add a stem and any other details you like, and you’re done!
While we’re on the subject of Halloween, I wanted to share another tip.
As much as I love making Halloween cookies I hate it that almost every traditional Halloween color has that poopy bitter taste {black, orange, and purple, some reds, ect.} So, I do what I can to make any color possible as tastless as possible.
This isn’t rocket science, but sometimes it’s the simple things that make the biggest difference. Remember when I shared my secret to no-taste red?
I used the same idea to create no-taste orange. I mix tulip red with a yellow color {going back to grade school color mixing},
And I end up with a nice, non-bitter orange color. Any yellow works, even electric version.
Play with it a little and you’ll end up with a completely custom orange color, and you’ll be doing a lot to take some of the icky taste out of your Halloween cookie collections!
If you haven’t had enough of me yet, you should hop on over to Confessions of a Cookbook Queen. I’m hijacking her blog for a day while she’s off eating good food and watching football in New Orleans.
Anyway, today is the beginning of a new week. I hope it turns out to be a great one for everyone!
Happy Halloween baking everyone!
Perfect Jack o’Lantern Cookies? Yes, yes, and yes! Love them!
Callye — I LOVE how you add dimension to all of your cookies. I’m so glad you shared how you did it with the witch boot cookies. Seriously, I can’t get over how much better these pumpkins look with the face slightly in from the rest of the pumpkin. I LOVE IT!!
I know, the dimension is fantastic….they look life like. She does great work.
These are so stinkin cute! I love the recessed jack o’lantern face.
Yes I am laughing 🙂 And I love how puffy these little guys are.
love, love, love these pumpkins. they look so animated.
Awesome cookie! I wanted to share with your readers ~ Michaels has a set of 20 Halloween metal cutters on clearance for $4.99! 10 lg cutters and 10 small versions. haunted house, coffin, candy corn, cat, ghost, etc! I was so happy to find them!!!
These pumpkins are ADORABLE, I love how textured they are, so fun!!!
I read your post and wished I’d wreittn it
I love that green color you used. Did you create that green color, too?
I mixed it up…it’s actually Yoda leftovers, lol….but try americolor avocado. Its pretty much the same…o just ran out 🙂
These jacked up tips are great! I love the step by step for embedding the features and building dimension with the sections, plus the color mixing tips. I’m about to do some pumpkin cookies for my daughter’s kindergarten class and after reading this post, I feel armed and ready!
You are so right about the icky, bitter taste some colors have. These are all great tips, from the Tulip Red (no-taste red), to the sectioning of the jack-o-lantern. You’re a great teacher, Callye. Thank you!! Miss you, girl :0)
wishing i read this post before i spent the day making jack o lantern cookies!! oh well… if i need to make any more before halloween comes next wknd, i will definitely try it this way, adding the black face first!
omg they’re great ! I love their cheeky faces. Thanks for sharing 😀
Your Jacks are just too cute! Love the dimension and colors, and what a great tip for the orange. Um… can I EVER get enough of the amazingly creative OCD Callye??? NEVER!
Awesome!! I had been wanting to put a face on a dimensional Jack and knew I couldn’t get it perfect by just piping on another level. I hadn’t put much thought in figuring out an alternative, so thank you sooooo much for doing the foot work and sharing!!
Wow, they turned out really nice! Happy Halloween! 🙂
Pingback: MiszelkowySchowek's soup
These are fantastic! I love that orange!
I so wish I had time to make Halloween cookies,maybe this week, I haven’t done any this year! I’m happy thought that you are making them so I get to see some cool ideas and I always appreciate you taking the pictures how you make them, it is fun to see. Gosh I love that orange!!!
Perfect for Halloween!
Fantastic work Callye! I need to order some tulip red. Making Orange never seems to be the shade I’m looking for. I’ll try your tip. I love the way you add depth to the cookies. Wonderful tutorials.
Yep, Sugar Belle – you’ve done it again! these are PERFECT!
LOVE the definition you are able to create with your icing. I think you need to take a vacation out to California and just bake with me for a week. I have SO much to learn. It’s a plan. Right? 🙂
So SO cute! I love them 🙂
these are super cute! oh and I love the Confessions of a Cookbook Queen cookies you did. I totally wanna be made into a cookie now. 😉
love these! I may add them to the 11 dozen cookies I have to make this week 🙂
Thanks for the tip!!!! Especially since I can never seem to get a true orange form the orange gel pastes alone without using a ton of it!!!! Not sure why I never thought to mix red and yellow. Duh! The punkins’ are super cute too!!
Hi, came over from Created by Diane’s Facebook link and love your blog. The texture and personality in these cookies make them almost animated. Love our talent~
Hi, came over from Created by Diane’s Facebook link and love your blog. The texture and personality in these cookies make them almost animated. Love your talent~
Thanks for the great tutorial! You’re jack-o-lantern cookies are definitely perfect! No way I could draw that straight of a line (let alone 4 or 5 on each cookie) and I probably wouldn’t have enough patience to actually wait before filling in the whole cookie either LOL But, I love this and I may just have to try it and see how it goes anyway! Thanks for all your inspiring posts! 🙂
It’s my turn to be lost for words. Every cookie you make is a work of art, art that has a clear Callye stamp on it. STUNNING!
Callye, Thanks SO MUCH for for sharing all of your great tips. Next time I’m going to make/decorate a cookie(or two) I need to refer back to your blog before I begin…You have so much here that I forget all of the valuable nuggets you share! 🙂 Your pumpkin looks fantastic!
Callye I wish I had little kids to make these for; I honestly think the cutest pumpkin cookies I’ve ever seen1
Thank you this looks so wonderful! Does it drive you crazy to sit and do so many? I don’t mind a dozen but more makes me crazy!
THANKS FOR YOUR TIPS…VERY HELPFUL!
Perfection!
So pretty! I like the three dimensionality and the perfect little curls of the green vines.
Wow. Your cookies are amazing! You are incredibly talented. Thank you for taking the time to share with all of us. One of these days I’m going to give one of your beautiful cookies a try at home. How fun!
~ Caren Smith
http://www.MyScrapbookStudio.net
I love the shape of this cookie cutter. Your pumpkins are adorable. I recently mixed yellow and red for pumpkin cookies and got the best orange colour I think I’ve ever had 😉
Pingback: Halloween Party Treats | Free Pattern & Tutorial at CraftPassion.com
Those are absolutely adorable. you have a gift!!!
Pingback: The Easiest Eyeball Cookies You Will EVER Make
Pingback: Cookies… cookies… and MORE cookies! | Diva Entertains Blog
Pingback: Edible Jack O’Lantern Treats | Yummly
I love the face on the Jack O’ Lantern…it’s perfect!!! And Thank you for explaining how to get that “puff” look that gives all your cookies such amazing dimension!!!
I love these puffy jack-o-lanterns! So cute and classic.
They’re gorgeous! Sugar cookies are a fav at our house but they rarely make it to the icing stage 🙂
They look sooooo cute! You did an awsome job.
Your cookies are BEAUTIFUL! This Halloween I made my FIRST cookie…a big fat candy corn…I used your
technique to made each section POP…THANK you for your tutorials….I am NOT an ARTIST (like you), but
my cookie came out pretty good….I mean it’s a candy corn!? Wish there was someone in my area like you
that sold cookies…because I ABSOLUTELY have NEVER seen anyone with your talent…seriously!
Thanks for sharing your cookie SENSE!
I love this tutorial! You really have a great blog:)! Cant wait to try it!
I love this idea! I have the same problem with “OCD and liking realistic”. Great tip on the no-taste orange.
My main concern is blacks and reds seem to seep into other colors that they touch. Some times the next day the colors have un attractively melded. Any suggestions??
These are GREAT! I like every cookie you do.
Your cookies are so cute.
Love these! Where did you get the cookie cutter?
I came out of a peanuts cookie mix set the year before last….I might have gotten it at hobby lobby or wold market.
Where do you get these pumpkin cookie cutters?
Pingback: Happy Thanksgiving! (Fall Cookies) « by amber's hands
Your trick to get orange totally saved my butt today. I started out with a nasty looking mess but finished with a perfect orange for basketball cookies. Thanks!!
Thanks so much for this blog. I am pretty much completely new to the world of cookie decorating and your blog will help me from making some rookie mistakes. My goal is to make Auburn/Alabama cookies for and take them to my In-Laws Iron Bowl party. So I will be using both the no-taste orange and no-taste red methods. You’re a lifesaver! You are very talented BTW.
You are my hero!!!! I love these. I am teaching a cookie decorating class at the end of September, would you mind if I did these? I always send people to your site first. Thanks for sharing!!
Would you mind sharing where you got your pumpkin cookie cutter?
I think it came out of a Charlie Brown kit I got at World Market..
Pingback: Pretty Autumn Color Palette
Hi, I need to ake orange coloring but do not have access to Tulip red on hand right now. Can I use super red or will that not work? Thanks!
Pingback: Black and Orange Halloween Snack Ideas for Kids: Top 11 Recipes | Food For Thought
Pingback: Making Halloween Green Icing
Pingback: Kids Halloween Party Inspiration Board | Paperspice
Pingback: Blog Love: Halloween Baking
These are adorable and I will attempt to make these this weekend. Just a quick question…. Not sure if I overlooked this on the post or in the comments, but did you use regular flood icing for the eyes and mouth and 20 second frosting for the pumpkins? I just want to be sure I use the right consistency to achieve the perfect look!
Pingback: Hearty pumpkin soup | sinsationscakes
I have spent a lot of time on your blog over the last few weeks. Your information and tutorials are helpful. I am a good baker, but have never decorated cookies. Today, I started with your help and advise. I actually had pumpkin cookie cutters, so I tried my hand at your method shown above. While my cookies don’t look like yours do, they are a great beginning place. Thanks for the help.
Pingback: Sweetness Made from Home: Jack-o-Lantern - Things To Do Yourself - DIY
Pingback: EVERYDAYEPHEE.COM | INSPIRE + EXPERIENCE.
Can you share where you got the stencil for the face of the Jack O’ Lantern? It’s adorable!! I’ve been looking for other stencils to put on cookies too, primarily letters in different fonts. Any idea where I can find those?
Hi there, those Jack O Lamtern cookies are so adorable!! I’m new at this, what did you mean by thicker flood icing being between 12-20 seconds? Is that the count you would do as you are filling in? Do you have a favorite sugar cookie recipe and flood icing recipe that you can share. My sugar cookies always spread and never turn out looking like what the cutter does. Please help.. Thank you
What cookie cutter was used for the Jack O’Lantern? Looking at the bare cookie the shape looks like something else, possibly an apple? I can’t quite put my finger on it. thanks
Hi! Super cute cookies! Of course I tried to make them and they look horrible! How do you keep your frosting from not sticking up every time you stop a line (for instance when you trace the face). Is it that my frosting is too thick? Because there was so much to trace my cookies just look bad with all the pointed mini mountains everywhere. Any tips would be great!