Lemon Poppy Seed Cutouts {Recipe}
I have never been overwhelmingly interested in New Year parties, and the older I get, the more apparent it becomes. I was SOOOO excited because this year I had nothing to do on New Year’s Eve but stay home and try out some of the recipes I have been working on.
They were all good, but my taste-testers (the Bern-Dogg family) picked a winner hands down…
I have wanted to test this cookie for a LONG time, but just never had the time. It made perfect sense to me, since some of my most favorite baked treats like scones and muffins are often this flavor.
I tried this recipe two ways. The first batch I iced with lemon royal icing, which is my RI flavored with vanilla and a splash of freshly squeezed lemon juice.
The bottled stuff is fine, but my next idea required real lemons anyway, so it only made sense to use the whole thing…
For the first batch, I made black-eye pea cutouts. They were very tasty, but for the second batch I wanted something simpler, and not as sweet. So, I decided to top them with lemon sugar.
To make the lemon sugar, I zested two whole lemons, and mixed the zest with half a cup of light yellow sanding sugar. {White sugar works just fine, but I was feeling “yellow”, so I went with sanding sugar}
As far as Bern-Dogg is concerned, if I only made THESE cookies for the rest of forever, that’s good enough for him …
And the best part is, the kids LOVED them. Surprisingly, they actually preferred these over the iced ones!
However if you are feeling industrious, this would be the PERFECT base cookie for something like this…
Ingredients
- 1c unsalted butter
- 1 ½ c confectioner’s sugar
- 1 egg
- 2 tsp lemon baker’s emulsion (I LOVE baker’s emulsion)
- 1 tsp vanilla
- 2 ¾-3 c all purpose flour
- 2 tsp baking powder
- 1tsp salt
- 2 tsp poppy seeds
Instructions
- Preheat Oven to 400 degrees.
- Cream together butter and confectioner’s sugar.
- Add to this the egg and flavorings.
- Sift together flour, baking powder, and salt, adding this mixture one cupful at a time to the wet ingredients.
- Mix until the dough forms a ball on the paddle.
- Roll out on floured parchment paper and cut into desired shapes.
- Bake at 400° for 7-8 minutes.
PS-Stay tuned later this week for my best giveaway yet!!!
I have a question? What is lemon emulsion? I think i have seen bakery emulsion. Is it like an extract? or what is the difference? Thanks . Great post!
WOW. YUM!!!!!
I love the idea of doing the lemon cut outs as the base for the decorated lemons and limes!
I can't wait to try these! Love the lemon and lime cookies!
I'm with Bern-Dogg on this one! I'm a big fan of lemon poppyseed anything, too. 🙂
Look forward to giving this recipe a try very soon. Thanks, Callye
I LOVE ALL THINGS LEMON!! Poppy seed is an added bonus! I can't wait to try this…thanks for sharing Callye!!
These COOKIES look good! (sorry I deleted the previous post)
I bet these are DELICIOUS!!!
@astheroshe literally taken from the site, a baker's emulsion is a water-based, alcohol-free alternatives to extracts. Instead of using alcohol, the flavor is micro encapsulated in natural stabilizers and suspended in water. The encapsulation enables the flavor to not lose its integrity when exposed to high heat.
In english and from experience, this means that more flavor stays in the cookie and does not burn off during baking.
I have experimented, and can vouch. Cookies are going to taste good regardless, but if you use the emulsion, it STAYS…plus they have some wonderful flavors…try the princess cake and cookie…LOVE!
oh they are calling my name! Isn't it funny about lemon….I read you comment 🙂 Now it's all about LEMON….YUM!!!! These are a must try!! Thanks.
Oh, I so want to make these!
These look so incredibly delicious. I don't know that they would look the same if I made them…but that's a risk I'm willing to take! Thank you for sharing this recipe!!
Ohhh thank you Callye on the "lesson" about emulsions!!! I just bought the orange one to try in gingerbread *ur recommendation* and was worried about the effects! And I was really wondering about the princess flavor too!!!!!
Wow!! Looks delish. Any thoughts about adding coconut bakery emulsion instead? I would love a coconut tasting cut out cookie- especially for a vacation themed cookie! Of course, it looks like Martha has a recipe for one, but the bakery emulsion sounds like it'd be good in that!
I have some more summer-y ones saved for when it warms up, Sue, although I admit, the end of gingerbread season makes u want to dive right into the lighter stuff! I'm excited for it to warm up 🙂
Hi! Is there any alternative for the lemon bakery emulsion? Like the lemon zest perhaps? I'm overseas, so it's kinda hard to find those things here. and I would really love to try this recipe. Thanks! =)
Anna, lemon extract will work just fine =)
We have a few hundred lemons on the tree in our backyard, and I'm always looking for new ways to use them up. These look delicious!
I'm excited for summer for another reason now—- we just got a blizzard, so now it's warm weather thoughts and warm weather cookies! I'll be patient!
I absolutely love lemon and poppyseed cake, so these cookies sound just wonderful to me!
nice post..
thank's for the information ^_^
please visit me too :
check it out
Wow, these sound delicious AND look beautiful! You are quite the cookie maker…everything looks amazing!
I just made these, and they are seriously amazing! Yum!
I made these this weekend using 2 tsp of lemon zest and 1 teaspoon lemon extract and I love them…enough to run an extra couple miles after eating too many of them.
Pingback: cinnamon raisin cut out cookies | Created by Diane
Pingback: Mint Cut-Out Cookies with Dark Chocolate Glaze Icing | Created by Diane
Pingback: Cherry Cookies with Cherry Icing | Created by Diane
I love ALL your cookies!!!!! 🙂
Pingback: EASY Sugar Cookie Recipe | Created by Diane
I love these cookies! I am wondering if you think it would be OK to leave out the poppy seed?
I made these yesterday! I subbed the baker’s emulsion for lemon extract and lemon juice, but they were still delicious! Thanks for a great recipe. =)
Pingback: “Try to Catch a Falling Star” Lemon Poppyseed Cookies | The Crafty Cook Nook
wow, these cookies are delicious and look pretty! Your amazing cookie maker …
How many2″/3″ cookies does this recipe make? about 2 dozen or more?
Pingback: Chip and Salsa Cookies
Oh…this is sooo late to be adding a comment and I hope that you see this one as I really want to make this recipe.
Are you saying that these cookies can be iced and decorated like a regular sugar cookie and the poppies won’t show through!
Approximately how many of the scalloped shape cookies does this batch of batter yield? Many thanks.